Launchpad is non-free
|Deletions are marked like this.||Additions are marked like this.|
|Line 85:||Line 85:|
| The [http://sayspy.blogspot.com/2006/06/request-for-test-trackers-to-get.html word on the street]: "We want the best solution possible without being political." Sounds like a minor BitKeeper incident in the making, but then SourceForge isn't entirely run on open source software, either. -- PaulBoddie
Launchpad is a collection of services including bug tracking, translations and specification tracking. It is the official Ubuntu bug tracker and is also used as the official bug tracker by about 150 upstreams. In addition, there are about another 250 communities which coordinate bugs between Launchpad and their own bug infrastructure.
Some of the highlights of Launchpad bug tracking are documented here:
Python Bugs Import
The Python bugs from Source Forge have been imported into a demonstration instance, also containing a copy of the production data:
Outgoing Email Filter
To avoid spamming uninterested people, the outgoing email for the demo Launchpad instance is being filtered. We can whitelist email addresses on request (email email@example.com). The infrastructure committee's emails are white listed:
- Brett Cannon (brett at python.org, bcannon at users.sourceforge.net)
- Richard Jones (richard at python.org)
- A.M. Kuchling (amk at amk.ca, akuchling at users.sourceforge.net)
- Martin v. Löwis (martin at v.loewis.de, loewis at users.sourceforge.net)
- Barry Warsaw (barry at python.org, bwarsaw at users.sourceforge.net)
- Thomas Wouters (thomas at python.org, twouters at users.sourceforge.net)
Accounts for each bug reporter, assignee or commenter have been created using the $USERNAME@users.sourceforge.net address. People can claim the account using the password recovery page:
For people who already had launchpad accounts, the $USERNAME@users.sourceforge.net account can be merged here:
Old Bug Numbers
Each imported SourceForge bug has a nickname assigned of the form "sfNNNN", where NNNN is the old bug number. This makes it easy to look up bugs by the old SF bug number. For example, [http://sourceforge.net/tracker/index.php?func=detail&aid=1101399&group_id=5470&atid=105470 bug 1101399] is accessible as [https://demo.launchpad.net/bugs/sf1101399]
The Launchpad email interface is described here:
For the demonstration launchpad instance, the bug submission email address is firstname.lastname@example.org and bugs can be updated with NNNN@bugs.demo.launchpad.net addresses.
Submitting new bugs or changing the status of a bug by email requires that the message be PGP signed with a key registered to your Launchpad account.
We welcome feature requests, which can be filed in Launchpad at:
Note that this URL is for the production Launchpad instance. Bugs filed against Launchpad in the demo instance will not be seen and may be blown away in the future.
Shorter bug URLs -- the main python bug listing URL will be shortened to https://demo.launchpad.net/python/+bugs
- ownership of python product set to python-infrastructure team
bug contact set to python-dev team, whose email address is set to the existing email@example.com (not added to the outgoing email filter though, so won't receive email).
SourceForge bug data imported.
- incoming and outgoing email support enabled for demo launchpad instance, subject to outgoing email whitelist.
- Where can I download this tracker and how can install it. I saw this already in the past but did not understand what to do.
- My understanding is that Launchpad is not free software; we're currently unable to examine the source to ensure it does what we expect (and *doesn't* do what we don't expect). Why is a non-free tracker being considered at all for Python?
The [http://sayspy.blogspot.com/2006/06/request-for-test-trackers-to-get.html word on the street]: "We want the best solution possible without being political." Sounds like a minor BitKeeper incident in the making, but then SourceForge isn't entirely run on open source software, either. -- PaulBoddie